At the height of its popularity, Joy product blow after blow. Three of their songs even Reached the Top 10 of the Billboard Hot 100, and another arrived at # 3. It seemed like every famous song or singer would eventually find its way to the show, and Gleeks loved to play the guessing game, wondering who among the cast would sing which song.
The show ended in 2015, after six years of phenomenal musical numbers. Since then, whenever a new Lady Gaga or Ariana Grande song comes out, Gleeks continues to play the guessing game. There are songs that Joy would have absolutely covered, no questions asked. Fans might never know how these covers would sound, but they can at least guess who would sing them.
ten “Rain On Me” by Lady Gaga Feat. Ariana Grande, sung by Rachel and Mercedes
Lady Gaga and Ariana Grande’s mega-hit reportedly made its way to the series sooner rather than later. And who better to cover it than JoyThe two biggest divas, Rachel and Mercedes? Their voices complemented each other beautifully, and the song’s resilience themes fit both characters perfectly.
It’s a shame fans never had just one Rachel and Mercedes duet, Season 2’s “Take Me or Leave Me”. “Rain on Me” would be the perfect song for them both, with Mercedes covering the verses of Gaga and Rachel assuming the sweetest parts of Ariana.
9 “Shape Of You” by Ed Sheeran, sung by Artie & Sam
In the winter of 2017, “Shape of You” was huge. The song was everywhere, whether it was at a club or on Target’s speakers. Ed Sheeran’s contagious tune seemed inescapable, eventually becoming the top performing song of 2017 on the Billboard Hot 100.
“Shape of You” would be a good choice for the Dalton Academy Warblers. However, regular cast members Artie and Sam would also do the song justice. The more moving voice of the first would blend perfectly with the baritone of the boy group of the second, as evidenced by their duets in the series “Fire and Rain” and “Werewolves of London”.
8 “Havana” by Camila Cabello, sung by the unholy trinity
Although Camila Cabello’s “Havana” was released in October 2017, it peaked in 2018. Joy reportedly covered it in what would have been its ninth season, somewhere around September 2019.
“Havana” would have been an excellent choice for JoyThe resident bad girls, Quinn, Santana and Brittany. It’s a total sin that fans have only ever had two Unholy Trinity numbers that all three of them sang in. This pop hit would allow each of their voices to stand out and show off their dancing skills.
7 “Closer” by The Chainsmokers Feat. Halsey, sung by Kurt and Blaine
Kurt and Blaine are a fan favorite couple, but they’ve been through their share of the drama. The show ends with them about to welcome a baby, seemingly reaching the happy ending they’ve always wanted. However, all true Gleeks know their dynamics are volatile, and it wouldn’t be surprising if something went wrong with their marriage.
“Closer,” by the Chainsmokers starring Halsey, was a huge hit in the summer of 2016. Kurt and Blaine would likely sing it during their trial split in Season 7, as the former stayed in New York and the latter moved to Los Angeles.
6 Ariana Grande’s “7 rings”, sung by Brittany and Santana
Ariana Grande released “7 Rings” in January 2019 as the second single from her album, Thanks, next. He debuted No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100. The song channels the melody of The sound of music“My Favorite Things” from “My Favorite Things” and the lyrics deal with themes of friendship, intimacy and materialism.
“7 Rings” would suit Brittany and Santana perfectly. The two would dominate the song’s trap-pop mix while capturing its overall essence. The lyrics also fit their storyline perfectly, as they’ve always enjoyed the finer things in life.
5 “Shallow” by Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper, sung by Rachel and Blaine
‘Shallow’, the 2018 Oscars hymn song A star is born, has Rachel and Blaine written all over the place. In fact, Lea Michele and Darren Criss had it in their setlist during their 2018 LM / DC tour with great success.
“Shallow” wouldn’t have needed a reason to be played. However, the writers reportedly found a way to make it part of the story. Maybe the movie will become a Broadway musical with Rachel and Blaine as the main ones? Blaine may be too young for the male lead, but weird things have happened Joy.
4 Lizzo’s “Juice”, sung by Mercedes and Tina
Tina Cohen-Chang was part of Joy of the pilot episode. However, she never had the chance to be in the spotlight. Every time she sang, however, she’s proven her voice to be as good as any on the show. His duets with Mercedes, in particular, remain among the strongest in the history of the series, with “Dog Days Are Over” starring.
Lizzo’s “Juice” would be an amazing song for these two to sing. It would be a fun, energetic number that Tina and Mercedes would knock out of the park. Lizzo could also make a guest appearance.
3 “Bad Guy” by Billie Eilish, sung by Quinn
There’s no way “Bad Guy” wouldn’t be covered on the show if it was still on the air. The song was a massive hit in 2019, reaching No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 and winning the Grammy Awards for Record and Song of the Year.
In reality, Santana or even Rachel would have probably covered “Bad Guy”. However, there is no denying that Quinn’s voice would be ideal for the song. Quinn never got the same attention as some of the other female characters, that’s right, but her voice goes so well with the song that the writers probably would have asked her to come back just so she could sing the song.
2 “Lover” by Taylor Swift, sung by Rachel
In fact, any Taylor Swift song from her Reputation or Lover era would have felt like home Joy. However, this sweet, heartfelt and romantic melody would be the most welcome inclusion. “Lover” was a huge hit for Swift, with critics praising its nostalgic but whimsical lyrics.
“Lover” is an indie-folk ballad that would perfectly showcase Rachel’s voice. The character excelled at singing ballads and she gave a lovely rendition of the song that would appeal to both Taylor fans and the Gleeks who watched the show week after week.
1 “I can’t stop the feeling!” By Justin Timberlake, sung by New Directions
Justin Timberlake released his disco-pop song “Can’t Stop the Feeling!” in March 2016. The song starred as the lead single from the animated film’s soundtrack Trolls. “I can’t stop the feeling!” was Timberlake’s greatest song in a long time, eventually becoming the Best Performing Song of 2016. It also earned it an Oscar nomination for Best Original Song.
This tune, with its infectiously positive lyrics and infectious rhythm, would make a great band act. New Directions members past and present came together in a big song and dance number, celebrating life, love and of course music.
NEXT: Glee: Ranking Every Song Caught More Than Once
The Vampire Diaries: 10 plot twists no one saw coming
About the Author